• Previous message: [greg-dev] PostgreSQL support
  • Next message: [greg-dev] Thoughts on rating system
  • Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]

    [greg-dev] Thoughts on rating system

    Hello,
    no, I'm not dead, I've been thinking and working on the rating system,
    and was hoping I could some advice from you folks.
    
    Here is what is bothering me:
    
    a) Logic. What should non-admins see? Ideally I'd like to mimic the
    tagging policy, e.g. show a read-only rating for items that have been
    rated, nothing at all on the others. The problem here is that the
    current implementation doesn't offer a simple way to render a
    read-only rating.
    
    b) CSS. The current implementation uses a very ugly CSS hack to
    display the stars next to the "Rating" label. This breaks horribly on
    non-English locales (just try and switch to German to see what I mean)
    
    c) Markup. The current implementation downloads a s***load of markup
    for every item.
    
    d) License. I'm not sure the original author actually released his
    code under a "public" license. [
    http://komodomedia.com/blog/index.php/2005/08/24/creating-a-star-rater-using-css/
    ]
    
    
    Possible solutions:
    
    - move the rating system to the dynamic item-editing dialog. This
    would fix c) and possibly b) but would hide the rating from non-admins
    and require an additional click to rate items.
    
    - find a whole new implementation, maybe more javascript than CSS
    based. Could possibly resolve c) and probably b)
    
    
    What are your thoughts on this?
    Thanks,
    
     -m
    
    
    Posted by Marco Bonetti [reply] at Tue Sep 13 18:47:01 CEST 2005